Beth Howard & Co.
Star-filled Milky Way above a dark mountain range at night.

Why Lafayette Is Called the Star City

Beth Howard November 9, 2026

Nobody knows who first called Lafayette the Star City. The county historical association says no reliable source names the person, so the story rests on tradition.

Where did "Star City" come from?

Claims for Lafayette as the "Star City of the West" appeared as early as the 1830s, when Indiana was still the West. The name came out of a rivalry between river towns. Cincinnati was the "Queen City of the West," and each town led the shipping on its river, the Ohio and the Wabash.

The town behind the name

  • May 25, 1825: William Digby lays out the town and names it for the Marquis de Lafayette
  • 1826: Tippecanoe County is formed with Lafayette as its seat, and a steamboat docks at a wharf on lower Main Street
  • 1841: The Wabash and Erie Canal reaches Lafayette
  • 1852 to 1861: Five rail lines begin running from the city

Where the name went

Local businesses picked it up. There was a Star City Bottling Works, a Star City Building and Loan Association, and "Star City Soap" from the M. J. Schnaible Company, which the historical association calls a household item of its day.

More recently the name hung on Star City Coffee, which opened at 210 Main Street in January 2012. Listings now mark that shop closed.

Tomorrow: the art museum that started with $1 memberships in 1909.

Sources, read November 14 and 17, 2026: Tippecanoe County Historical Association, "Lafayette, Indiana: Star City of the West" (written 1974); City of Lafayette, City History; Yelp, Star City Coffee (listed as closed).

Work With Beth

Experience honest advice, constant communication, and a low-pressure process built around your goals.